[Verse 1]
Remember when I called you on the telephone
You were so far away
It was raining in New York, did I forget to say
It was later than I wanted it to be
On an early summer's night
The kind where you can't help but feel alive and free

And I told ya:
"From here on out, it's you and me"

[Chorus x2]
Shouldn't we?
Should we be?
Should we be together?
For, like, ever girl?

[Verse 2]
We drove across the bridge and I knew that we'd be okay
On an early summer's day
No clouds up in the sky, did I forget to say
You'd been up all night before
I barely slept at all
It's the kind of thing that's sure to make you feel so small

And I asked ya:
"Did you remember that phone call?"

[Chorus x2]

Do you think we should be together?
For ever and ever and ever and ever and ever...

[Chorus x2]

Don't you think we should be together?
For ever and ever...