A wise man told me that there's nothing new under the sun
What were you thinking when you told me that I wasn't the one?
Got the blues from the news, gotta stop having some fun
What were you thinking when you told me I wasn't the one?

Sugar and spice ain't nice anymore
Giving you good advice you ignore
Everything so precise, it's a bore
I been pushed to the brink
Now tell me, what do you think?
Tell me, baby

Surprise in my eyes, told me we were over and done
What were you thinking when you told me that I wasn't the one?
What were you thinking?

Even Captain Kirk had mercy when he set his phasers on stun
So what were you thinking when you told me that I wasn't the one?

Sugar and spice ain't nice anymore
Giving you good advice you ignore
Everything so precise, it's a bore
I been pushed to the brink
Now tell me, what do you think?
Tell me, baby

Sugar and spice ain't nice anymore
Giving you good advice you ignore
Everything so precise, it's a bore
I been pushed to the brink
Now tell me, what do you think?
Tell me, baby

The love that we made's been invaded like Attila the Hun
What were you thinking when you told me that I wasn't the one?
Treated you fair and was there when you needed someone
What were you thinking when you told me that I wasn't the one?
What were you thinking when you told me that I wasn't the one?
What were you thinking?